Assessing 49ers Overreactions: Evaluating Shanahan’s Play-Calling and Defensive Challenges

As the 49ers emerged from the divisional round with a narrow victory over the Green Bay Packers, various aspects of their performance have sparked discussions and overreactions. Let’s delve into the key points raised by Matt Maiocco:

1. Shanahan’s Play-Calling Can Be a Liability:

• Maiocco acknowledges that when Coach Kyle Shanahan’s play-calling works, it seems unstoppable, but questions arise about whether it’s the plays or the exceptional execution by players that make it effective.
• Highlighting a peculiar play where the wrong wristband led to an unexpected run by receiver Jauan Jennings, Maiocco suggests that the offensive rhythm was disrupted at times.
• While crediting Shanahan for success when the offense is rolling, the article emphasizes the scrutiny he faces when things don’t go smoothly.

2. Defensive Struggles Against the Run Persist:

• Despite returning key player Arik Armstead, the 49ers struggled against the Packers’ rushing game, allowing 108 yards to Aaron Jones.
• The article points out that the 49ers need to improve their run defense, especially with a challenging matchup against the Lions’ rushing duo of Jahmyr Gibbs and David Montgomery in the NFC Championship Game.

3. Ambry Thomas’ Performance Raises Concerns:

• Ambry Thomas, targeted by the Packers, faced challenges during the game, flagged for pass-interference penalties and allowing receptions.
• While labeled as an overreaction, the article suggests that if Thomas shows signs of lost confidence or struggles, the team may need to consider a change in the cornerback position.

4. Dre Greenlaw’s Impactful Plays:

• Linebacker Dre Greenlaw’s game-changing plays, including a fourth-down stop and two interceptions, are praised.
• The article notes that while Greenlaw’s contributions were significant, he received support from teammates, emphasizing the collective effort in pivotal moments.

5. 49ers Must Improve for Future Success:

• Despite the win, the 49ers’ overall performance is criticized for appearing choppy, rusty, and below their standard.
• The article concludes that such a level of play won’t be sufficient in upcoming games, suggesting that the 49ers need a considerable improvement across all facets to advance further.

As the 49ers prepare for the NFC Championship Game, addressing these concerns becomes crucial for their journey towards Super Bowl LVIII.